Wednesday Misunderstands Its Misunderstood Protagonist

While Tim Burton’s Wednesday definitely makes an attempt to mimic the aesthetic of the ‘90s Addams Family films, the surrounding plot and characters of Netflix’s latest teen drama fails to seize the morbid allure of Charles Addams’ gothic household.

The eight-episode Netflix collection follows Wednesday (Scream’s Jenna Ortega) as she makes an attempt to resolve a grisly homicide that occurred within the woods exterior of her new faculty, Nevermore Academy. She additionally digs into the historical past of Jericho—the small city that performs host to the varsity—and its founding father, Joseph Crackstone, a infamous witch-hunter who has a bloody connection to one in every of Wednesday’s ancestors.

At Nevermore Academy, the boarders transfer properly past creepy and kooky; werewolves, vampires, sirens, gorgons, telekenetics, and shapeshifters are all in attendance. What this implies is that Wednesday Addams is not an outcast amongst “normies,” supported by her household of fellow weirdos, however is positioned as an outcast amongst supernatural creatures, with out the help of her household and with a monitor report for preferring the corporate of disembodied palms to her fellow college students.

It’s a irritating watch; Jenna Ortega does the very best she will along with her traces, however Wednesday’s trademark deadpan sarcasm and unending distress makes her a painful lead character. The one-liners that labored when Wednesday was a part of an ensemble solid merely don’t land. She’s impassive, egocentric, and self-obsessed. She makes use of her mates, dismisses the boys who’re making an attempt to take her out on dates (for some unknown motive, since she hasn’t a lot as mentioned a single type factor to anybody), and routinely accuses her mother and father of assorted acts of sabotage, smothering, and even homicide.

The level of the Addams Family is that they’re simply acceptable sufficient to be tolerated by their regular neighbors, whereas additionally staying true to their bizarre and wacky roots. They train “normal” folks the way to work together with folks in contrast to themselves, and settle for each sort of particular person into their arms wholeheartedly. The drawback with Wednesday is that it continuously reinforces the variations between “normies” and “outcasts,” going as far as to make a really trite twist on the finish, as a result of after all it’s the normies who had been the actual monsters all alongside. If I might roll my eyes laborious sufficient to have them fall out of my head they might have been spinning on the bottom by the second episode.

This is a frustratingly easy takeaway that’s emblematic of the present itself. It talks right down to its teenage viewers, presenting banal black-and-white problems with morality and melodrama with the sort of grim dedication of an executioner’s axe. Will Wednesday go to the varsity dance with tortured outcast artist Xavier or the earnest townie barista Tyler? Is the monster within the woods being managed by an outcast or a normie? Did Gomez Addams actually kill a romantic rival whereas attending Nevermore or not? All of those questions are answered, and not one of the solutions matter. With lock-step predictability, you might most likely guess the solutions proper now and be proper, with none nuance hooked up in anyway.

And then there’s the model of this present. The costumes definitely do numerous work—each Wednesday and Enid (Wednesday’s bubbly werewolf roommate, performed by Emma Myers) are exceptionally well-dressed—however there isn’t numerous design occurring elsewhere. This was maybe the largest let down for me, particularly as I went into this collection hoping that Tim Burton’s aesthetically pleasing, overly stylized style would make this at the least a visually-interesting watch. Not so. Wednesday is disappointingly bland.

Without the restriction of condensed units, and with numerous vital conversations happening in a Jericho coffeeshop fairly than in Nevermore Academy, there’s little flourish to the overly-dark scenes. Shot in low lighting and amid a lot of rain, doom, and gloom, Wednesday hardly ever makes herself memorable, disappearing into the shadows of her personal present. The exceptions to this happen in the course of the two scenes the place she is taking part in the cello, and her intense resting corpse face truly works with Danny Elfman’s occasionally-magnificent rating. However, the true loss of life knell for this present is the truth that Wednesday is supported by a killer solid that features each Christina Ricci and Gwendoline Christie, and nonetheless no person stands out.

The forgettability of Wednesday might be a results of this character getting a complete collection devoted to her persona, which, because it seems, isn’t that humorous when her schtick simply repeats itself a dozen instances every episode. The character commits to the gothic/morbid bit, however fails to pursue any pursuits which can be actually macabre. The greatest instance of that is when the varsity dance is pranked and pink liquid pours from the sprinkler system. Wednesday licks some off her finger and sighs—it’s not even actual pig’s blood!

Girl, did you suppose it will be? This is mainly a CW present. Dyed water is the closest factor you’ll get to actual macabre humor the entire collection. The present is rather more involved with Wednesday’s a number of no-chemistry love pursuits and increase to an enormous, CGI-heavy, end-of-season struggle sequence (sure, actually) than it’s making any actual try at romanticizing the macabre.

The closest cross this present has with wit is thru dry and humorless twists on idioms. “I don’t bury hatchets. I sharpen them.” “If you hear me screaming bloody murder, there’s a good chance I’m just enjoying myself.” “Tortured writer, emphasis on torture.” These traces, delivered gracelessly and with maudlin teenage self-importance, ought to have been stored to elevator commercials and twee billboards. Instead, Burton has taken these pale imitations of the ‘30s and ‘40s New Yorker one-liner style of the original Addams Family comic strip and imagined it could last through an eight-episode show. Like many of these overwrought jokes, he is gravely mistaken.

Wednesday is now streaming on Netflix.

Want more io9 news? Check out when to expect the latest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on movie and TV, and all the things that you must find out about James Cameron’s Avatar: The Way of Water.