Let’s stipulate, first, that no Olympic sport is simple. Relaxing, kicking again, lounging round—these are usually not actions that may lead you to the Olympic Village. If I used to be an Olympian, I’d most likely take problem with some bodily deteriorated web author telling me that softball’s a relative breeze. Which is truthful. But—granted that each Olympic sport requires abilities of agility and focus missing in most of us, and particularly missing in me—there are nonetheless, inevitably, levels of problem. Some sports activities are more durable than others. But which one’s the toughest? For this week’s Giz Asks, we reached out to various consultants to search out out.

Read additionally: The Seemingly Cursed Tokyo Olympics Are Now within the Path of a Tropical Storm, No, Olympic Athletes Aren’t Being Asked to Sleep On ‘Anti-Sex’ Beds, Just Cancel the Damn Olympics Already

Associate Professor, Instruction in Sport, Management University of Texas at Austin

Given that you simply’re asking this query as we put together for the beginning of the Tokyo Summer Games, I’m going to simply ignore the Winter sports activities altogether. In the spirit of this Olympic second, I’m additionally going to remove any sports activities that aren’t featured within the Tokyo Games. (Sorry, American soccer, polo, cricket, and squash.) That leaves us with 33 contenders, a few of which have been featured in each trendy Olympics (athletics, aquatics, biking, fencing, and gymnastics) and a few of that are making their Olympic debut (karate, skateboarding, sport climbing, and browsing).

Now that we’ve narrowed all the way down to our 33 opponents, issues begin to get attention-grabbing.

If we expect when it comes to a Venn diagram the place we’ve two circles indicating the 2 most simple components that might make a sport exhausting—physiological exertion and complexity of talent/motion—then the hardest sport can be categorised the place these two circles overlap. In different phrases, a sport that’s demanding in each the bodily and the talent necessities. Can we establish sports activities of these 33 that clearly don’t fall in a single class or the opposite? Since just about any sport being performed on the Olympics requires a excessive stage of respective talent, maybe it’s best to make the primary minimize on the physiological aspect. Are there sports activities that don’t require maximal exertion throughout competitors? That eliminates, at a minimal, archery or equestrian sports activities. Next, will we imagine it to be more durable psychologically to compete solo than to be a part of a crew? You could disagree, but when so, then we are able to take away the crew sports activities from competition. Another query to debate is whether or not we imagine that it’s more durable to be competing in opposition to nature (for instance, kayaking or crusing) and/or on a course (for instance, biking or golf or skateboarding), or whether or not it’s more durable to be competing in a sport the place a fellow Olympic-level athlete is bodily making an attempt to stop your success. Assuming the latter, that will imply that we’ve narrowed all the way down to solely contemplating a physiologically-demanding particular person sport the place the opponents should straight overcome their opponent as a way to win. That leaves us with boxing, fencing, judo, karate, desk tennis (singles), taekwondo, tennis (singles), and wrestling. Remove desk tennis and tennis because of the lack of direct bodily confrontation, and we’re left with, proper or mistaken, our most historic types of hand-to-hand fight. Take away fencing due to the extra layers of padding/safety, and our decisions are basically boxing, one of many martial arts, or wrestling. At this remaining stage, one method to additional differentiate can be to look at the size of the matches throughout the respective remaining sports activities. After some fundamental calculations, the three potential rounds of three minutes apiece in an Olympic boxing match affords the longest potential match time of any of those sports activities.

So: Is boxing the hardest sport? According to our method, you possibly can actually make an excellent case for it. But perhaps we missed one thing and went astray in our mannequin someplace alongside the way in which. Is it more durable to be pummeled by the fists of an equivalent-sized human for as much as 9 minutes, or is it more durable to to swim 10 km (marathon swimming) or to finish a triathlon or to attempt to keep afloat and rating a aim whereas somebody is dragging you underwater (water polo)? Without the advantage of a managed laboratory setting, we’ll have to simply embrace the uncertainty and benefit from the festivities. USA! USA!

Professor within the College of Education at Florida State University and Director of FSU COACH: Interdisciplinary Center for Athletic Coaching

There isn’t any definitive reply to which Olympic sport is hardest, primarily as a result of every sport requires excellence in numerous areas. Archery, for instance, requires unbelievable hand-eye coordination, to not point out the flexibility to account for environmental variables comparable to wind velocity and course. In truth, archers have been recognized to have the ability to management their coronary heart fee in order that they launch the arrow between coronary heart beats. Compare this to determine skating, which requires energy, steadiness, and an acute consciousness of the motion of 1’s physique inside area. So, every occasion requires its personal experience.

For me, probably the most difficult sports activities throughout the Olympics are the multi-event sports activities. Perhaps probably the most troublesome of those are the decathlon (males) and heptathlon (ladies). They require the athlete to grasp physiological techniques which can be counter-intuitive. For instance, the javelin, 100 meters, and shot put, whereas extremely technical, require absolute energy from the physique. This is in distinction to the 1500 meters, for instance, that requires center distance endurance. So, the athlete should practice for energy and endurance on the identical time. The physique wants muscle for energy, but that very same muscle mass can impede endurance efficiency.

The second further problem that makes these occasions probably the most troublesome is that they happen over two days. This signifies that athletes can’t depend on a one-off efficiency to hold them to victory. They should time their meals, relaxation, psychological activation and restoration, and so forth to repeatedly carry out at their finest. This is each a psychological and bodily problem that, in my view, makes these occasions probably the most troublesome to grasp.

Director of the MS in Sport Management Program and Associate Professor of Sport Management at George Washington University

My reply can be gymnastics. To be on the gymnastics crew, it’s a must to have mastered not less than 4 totally different disciplines: the steadiness beam, the uneven bars, the ground train, and the vaults. Each one in every of these requires totally different skill-sets. The ground train requires inventive/dance abilities; the steadiness beam requires excessive psychological focus. If you lose that focus on the steadiness beam only one bit, you’re carried out—the steadiness beam is 4 inches. The room for error could be very small in gymnastics in comparison with crew sports activities. And every of those disciplines additionally requires totally different sorts of observe routines and totally different muscle teams.

All of that mentioned, synchronized swimming is likely to be the runner-up—all these strikes carried out underwater, whereas holding your breath…it’s not as simple because it appears to be like.

Teaching Specialist, Interdisciplinary Center for Athletic Coaching, Florida State University

Let me preface this by saying that you would most likely make an argument for any Olympic sport being probably the most troublesome. In making an attempt to type out my very own contender, I’ve restricted my choices to these sports activities being performed at this summer time’s Olympics, and considered 1) the age of the athlete and a couple of) the bodily and psychological/emotional stresses of the game. Taking all these components into consideration, I believe the toughest sport is gymnastics.

Oftentimes, gymnasts are youthful than lots of the opposite athletes on the Olympics. The youthful you might be, the more durable it’s to arrange, mentally and bodily. Then there’s the truth that gymnastics is an impression sport—it makes a tough impression on the physique fairly persistently. And whereas each sport comes all the way down to a matter of inches, in gymnastics it’s a matter of simply millimeters. If they’re off on their touchdown, or miss the bar, they’re dealing with professional accidents that might sideline them perpetually. Gymnasts additionally must be versatile, cell, and very robust. They want to have the ability to rigorously management their our bodies. A whole lot of coaching goes into that.

On the psychological aspect, there’s the concern of failure, which may destroy a gymnast. When you’re fearful of failure, you would possibly hesitate—and given the sorts of actions gymnastics require, any hesitation can result in catastrophe.

It’s true that gymnasts don’t must react to issues of their setting, which could make issues “easier” than some crew sports activities, however the different aspect of that’s the truth that the strain is positioned on the person to carry out: when you might have a pitcher on a softball area, the crew can choose them up. So I’m going to stay with gymnastics.

Professor Emeritus of Exercise & Sport Studies and Former Director of the Human Performance Lab at Smith College

The two that come to thoughts: 1) the two,000-meter rowing race and a couple of) the 1500-meter race that decathletes run.

Why? For any sport to be actually powerful, it has to have a major anaerobic impact. Both of these will lead contributors to generate fairly a little bit of lactic acid—after they end the race, they’ll have lots of lactic acid of their bloodstream, which is uncomfortable.

With the decathlon 1500-meter race, the rationale it’s exhausting for its contributors is that they’re not likely educated for it. They’re primarily coping with occasions that solely final seconds—the 100-meter sprint, excessive hurdles, shot put, discus, javelin, and so forth. So decathletes are usually not actually educated for distance occasions, as a result of you possibly can’t adequately practice for each. Which is why you typically see these athletes just about collapse on the finish of their occasions.

Professor of Sport Studies and Chair of the Division of Social Science & Communication at Manhattanville College

This is just not a straightforward query, as a result of it actually is determined by what you suppose makes something exhausting. Most disciplines to be taught? Then we must be speaking about decathlon, heptathlon, gymnastics, and the actually weird trendy pentathlon. Crazy correct precision? Archery blows my thoughts—these targets are so distant. I’m shocked each time they hit the goal, by no means thoughts the bullseye, and gold medals are misplaced and received by distances that the bare eye can barely see. Sports that make me shake my head in awe once I watch? Pole vault and hurdles, with the 400-meters proper up there (I imply, they throw up on the finish. Because it’s a distance run like a dash. It’s loopy. No pacing by any means).

But I believe I’ve to say—and I’m not alone on this—that water polo is the winner right here. I by no means noticed a water polo match till my first Olympics, in Atlanta, however once I obtained the task, I used to be throughout it. Obsessed. Those groups are enjoying hockey, lacrosse, and soccer whereas sustaining the viciousness of a soccer sport (significantly—check out the underwater digital camera to see what is basically occurring) and swimming miles per sport. I can’t fathom doing what water polo gamers do if I used to be standing on grass, by no means thoughts treading water that goes nicely over my head. The first time I watched it, I simply saved pondering: this can’t really be a sport. But it’s, and it’s superior.

Do you might have a burning query for Giz Asks? Email us at tipbox@gizmodo.com.