There is one thing deeply nostalgic about returning to the world of Supernatural. Sure, the entire thing lasted 15 seasons and solely simply led to 2020, however for me, Supernatural is the present that I watched on repeat in school, again in 2010. While there have been undoubtedly some extra absurd arcs in the direction of the top of that period of my life, the staples stay the good moments with the Four Horsemen, the interdimensional fights between Angels vs. Demons, numerous horrible Crowley and Bobby interactions, and naturally the introduction of the angel who has my everlasting affections, Castiel of Thursday.

This being stated, I’m the right viewers for Supernatural prequel collection The Winchesters: somebody who has lately watched the entire collection (all 350-ish episodes) and who additionally has fond recollections of watching at the very least by season seven in school. What I discovered through the premiere screening at New York Comic Con was that regardless of a little bit of a rocky, lore-heavy begin (one that basically drew from seasons eight and 12, each of which have been exceptionally centered on the Men of Letters), by the top of the episode I had watched a superbly first rate and pleasant 40 minutes of tv.

Will it enchantment to individuals who have by no means watched an episode of Supernatural? I actually couldn’t let you know; it’s not fairly as bizarre as related exhibits like Wynnona Earp and treads fairly style acquainted floor. It additionally requires a bit extra heavy lifting than the pilot of Supernatural did in 2005. While the performances are first rate, there’s plenty of awkwardness within the dialogue and the lighting is distinctly yellow in a manner that makes it appear to be the entire present was shot thorugh a sepia filter. The indisputable fact that Dean Winchester (Supernatural’s Jensen Ackles) is narrating doesn’t do a lot to persuade me that that is the present that can cross over right into a wider viewers.

The new collection focuses on John Winchester (Drake Rodger) and Mary Campbell (Meg Donnelly), the long run dad and mom of Sam and Dean Winchester (Jared Padalecki and Jensen Ackles), who’re the celebs of Supernatural. Now, the unique collection does plenty of work to construct up the relationships between Sam and Dean and their dad and mom, which ends up in plenty of daddy points and plenty of projection onto an absent mom who miraculously returns on the finish of season 11. Don’t ask me how, there’s a really Supernatural reply that can make little or no sense for those who do.

We’re (re-)launched to John and Mary in ways in which make it very clear that the brand new collection is deeply hooked up to the motion and construction of the unique. John is coming back from a stint with the Marines in Vietnam, and is suitably traumatized by the expertise. Mary is actually launched whereas beating up a demon and performing a really classically Supernatural exorcism spell. When we get to the crux of the episode—Mary’s father went on a looking journey and hasn’t been dwelling in a number of days—anybody who is aware of Supernatural will acknowledge that this preliminary premise is the inciting incident of the primary episode of the 2005 pilot. Because Mary’s father, Samuel, is lacking, she wants to interrupt right into a Men of Letters bunker to find out the place he may need gone. John joins her in her search of the hideout and realizes his father was a Man of Letters, and that this complete demon factor may be the rationale he skipped out on him and his mom years in the past.

With a stable base of daddy points, the present is already rewriting a number of the outdated episodes of Supernatural. There are fairly a number of episodes of the unique present the place Sam and/or Dean return in time and work together with their household, often coping with Mary, her impending demon deal, and her hunter upbringing. While the unique present established, fairly firmly, that John didn’t develop into a full-time hunter till after Mary died, The Winchesters performs with a little bit of a grey space that posits possibly John and Mary did some looking collectively, and so they each gave it up to be able to have a household.

It’s not fairly altering the details established within the unique, however there’s definitely somewhat little bit of a facet eye coming from followers, particularly when on the NYCC panel the showrunner Robbie Thompson–a longtime Supernatural author/director–stated that they weren’t going to rewrite what the present is doing. As prequels go, there’s definitely plenty of area to discover the Men of Letters, the adventures of John and Mary within the ‘70s, and to right some of the retrospective wrongs of the original show. Thompson said at the panel that by the end of the season it will be very clear that this show is setting itself apart from the original.

If this “wait until the end of the season to judge us” attitude rubs you the wrong way—fair. It’s 13 episodes of monster-of-the-week tv, I get it. But it’s form of the Supernatural option to spend the entire season monster looking in between arc constructing, and reveal an enormous twist within the thirteenth hour. But if the present continues to construct and increase on what we noticed within the first episode, I think will probably be a really entertaining season. It nails the tragicomedy vibes of the present, the place essentially the most devastatingly emotional traces are those usually delivered like a joke, and we have already got a supporting forged of characters that I personally would go to battle for.

The unique facets of The Winchesters are, maybe sadly for the present, significantly better than the bits of lore and the principle characters which have been ported from Supernatural. We meet two new hunters—Latika (Nida Khurshid of Station 19) and Carlos (Jonathan “Jojo” Fleites)—who’re instantly very charming, doubtless as a result of they aren’t weighed down by the identical baggage that John and Mary have to hold with them. Latika, referred to as Lata within the collection, is a scardey-cat lorehound who’s however determined to assist her pals. Carlos is a splendidly fey chaos bisexual who exhibits up in a hippie van and with an distinctive wardrobe and sense of timing. These two are actually fairly enjoyable, and whereas my fast response to John and Mary is extra of a “oh what trauma will we retread this time” form of second, Lata and Carlos are genuinely pleasant characters.

Mary and John are fascinating characters, and the present is working time beyond regulation to persuade us that their story will probably be fascinating regardless of us figuring out the ending. They flirt somewhat bit, the constantly-angry Mary Campbell utilizing her resting bitch face like plate armor as she slowly warms as much as the traumatized pet canine that’s John Winchester.

Ultimately, The Winchesters is a barely extra subtle, however nonetheless barely campy, model of Supernatural that isn’t held again by the absurdly expansive ranges of lore that Sam and Dean needed to cope with by season eight of a present that continued for seven extra years. Using all that as a basis appears to have given The Winchesters permission to discover sides of cyclical, generational trauma and produce actual depictions of PTSD to the forefront of their storytelling, meting out with metaphor because it instantly tackles the methods through which dad and mom fuck their children up in the identical methods they’ve been fucked up.

The Winchesters premiered on October 11, and airs Tuesdays on the CW.

Want extra io9 information? Check out when to count on the newest Marvel and Star Wars releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on movie and TV, and the whole lot you should learn about House of the Dragon and Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power.