After years of questioning when, not if, Mass Effect would ever make the leap from video video games to movie or TV, it could appear we’re ultimately on that precipice: Amazon has eyes on bringing BioWare’s sci-fi shooter/Garrus Vakarian relationship simulator to streaming. But the query needs to be much less if the Mass Effect collection ought to come to TV, however how—and the reply is with out its “main” character.

Commander Shepard is the star of the primary three video video games within the Mass Effect saga—within the fourth sport, Andromeda, it’s Ryder, a personality equally largely outlined by the participant. Shepard is beloved, though not maybe essentially as a result of they’re a fantastic character. Shepard is, in some methods, arduous to outline as having a persona while you scrape away the factor that makes Mass Effect nonetheless so cherished, and the factor that makes an try to adapt Commander Shepard’s story to a different medium such a harmful prospect: a lot of what we see in Shepard as gamers is what we ourselves put into them. Mass Effect is a sport franchise outlined by its incorporation of participant alternative, regardless of how clear typically the limitations that affect will be made inside its programs. Even if, on a macro scale throughout the video games, gamers’ selections are comparatively binary, or extra about filling within the little prospers right here and there relatively than the broadest strokes of its overarching story, Commander Shepard stays a deeply private character to individuals who play the Mass Effect video games. We do extra than simply management Shepard from one plot level to the subsequent, we information what they are saying and what they imagine in, we forge their friendships and their loves, we craft them as an individual. Are they man or girl, paragon or renegade, are they queer, are they conflict survivors or orphaned troopers, tech consultants or psychic space-wizards? All the little selections individuals pour into that character make Shepard much less of their very own particular person, for higher or worse, and as a substitute our window into their place in Mass Effect’s universe.

Shepard’s nature as that type of highly effective cipher makes the potential of a Mass Effect present merely making an attempt to adapt them and the occasions of the unique trilogy of video games one thing of a nightmare. It’s not that it can’t be accomplished—the video games have lengthy prided themselves on their cinematic framing and values, making it about as simple an adaptation because it may presumably be if actually translated. But bringing in a Shepard, whoever performs them, and making an attempt to set an outlined body across the nebulous concept of who Commander Shepard is, seems like asking for hassle: and asking for it from a fanbase that has, to place it diplomatically, very much proven how vocal they are often about issues they don’t like concerning the methods the collection dealt with their selections. Even what would possibly look like the easy alternative of whether or not or not adapting Shepard as John or Jane could be a call that upends Mass Effect’s fanbase, and that’s earlier than you even get to the granularity of weaving about their persona, their romances, or the way in which they conduct themselves throughout their story. So a lot of ourselves is wrapped up in our interpretation of Commander Shepard as Mass Effect gamers that the considered seeing some model that isn’t simply our personal could be jarring.

So why even do it? It’s not simply that adapting Shepard is a assured solution to disappoint the Mass Effect fan base in a technique or one other. Mass Effect’s world is dwelling to greater than only one story, and Shepard’s story has already been instructed. It’s a setting ripe for exploration past the battle between the Commander and the Reapers. A Mass Effect present may comply with in and across the shadow of Shepard—following characters we all know earlier than or after they crossed paths with Shepard, acquainted favorites like Kaidan, Liara, Garrus, Thane, or Tali (or maybe an anthology that might encapsulate the lives of its beloved expanded forged). It may present us the occasions that introduced us to Mass Effect’s begin level, just like the Rachni War and the Krogan rebellions that got here after, the Quarian’s creation of the Geth, and even the First Contact War between the Turians and Humanity. There are tales in between the video games, particularly the time period in Mass Effect 2‘s opening the place Shepard is, effectively, fairly useless (they get higher). With the addition of Andromeda to the canon, Mass Effect’s universe and potentiality exploded onto the scope of complete galaxies—and a present may discover what Andromeda arrange, seemingly left behind after that sport’s lukewarm reception, whereas we await no matter comes subsequent within the franchise.

We know what Shepard’s story is already, and most significantly to Mass Effect gamers, we all know what that story is to our own experience of the form of it. If we’re going to take the subsequent Mass Relay to TV stardom, Mass Effect ought to stand prepared to take action past the shadow of its first hero—and prepare to put the groundwork and introduce us to new ones past the Commander’s attain.

Wondering the place our RSS feed went? You can decide the brand new up one right here.