Star Trek: Lower Decks Feels Like It’s Back to Where This Season Started

Star Trek: Lower Decks has had a tough third season, with uncommon moments of eking out character development solid below the shadow of a regressive feeling of pulling principal characters touring paths they’d already navigated. Its finale, for higher or worse, at resets the present in some methods, so we will neglect most of this season really occurred.

Picking up from final week’s re-hash of the Captain Freeman/Mariner battle that drove the primary season of the present, “The Stars at Night” largely navigates away from that drama to offer us some suitably finale-worthy stakes. With Admiral Buenamigo’s Texas-class drone ships revealed and proved of their potential saving the Cerritos final week, he now strikes ahead in his plan to interchange the human crews of the California-Class shipswith his new drone vessels, threatening to place our heroes and all of their fellow assist vessels out of service.

The thought of drone ships is an fascinating conundrum for the Federation, particularly given the lengthy historical past we’ve seen of how Starfleet has dealt with, poorly or in any other case, the labor rights of non-organic beings in its service. What rights does the A.I. that controls a complete starship have? Are they officers within the fleet? What does it imply when these ships are put into drydock? Can you give a drone shore depart?

Since Lower Decks is a comedic journey firstly, this concept is essentially left unexplored, and as a substitute given over to the a lot funnier thought of Captain Freeman’s determined gambit to maintain the Cali ships in service: a race between the Cerritos and a Texas-Class drone on a sequence of rudimentary Starfleet missions, to see which ship performs them the quickest and to the passable normal. For essentially the most half, the race is neck and neck, till a choice by Ensign Tendi—the proper determination—to double verify if a planet is host to sentient microbial life not picked up on preliminary surveys means the Cerritos narrowly loses to the drone, and the destiny of the California ships seemingly sealed.

But any fascinating mental facet of this battle between the Texas and California lessons is sort of instantly kicked apart to disclose that Buenamigo will not be so Buen an amigo in any case: his victory assured, the Admiral reveals that it was his plan all alongside to undermine Carol to offer the Texas-Class ships the sting amongst his fellow Admirals, and even worse, he’s the architect behind Rutherford’s reminiscence loss, hiding the truth that the Texas A.I. is predicated on none aside from the code for psycho hologram “helper” Badgey from the primary season of the present. While Badgey’s return—and, because of the mid-credits scene, a reveal that he’s nonetheless round for extra villainy—is a pleasant shock, pinning the potential curiosity of the Texas-Class’ existence in Starfleet on the twist that it’s actually simply one other bog-standard Star Trek Admiral-gone-bad utterly undercuts it.

It does not less than give “The Stars at Night” some suitably explosive stakes. As the Texas ships activate Buenamigo and promptly kill him, it’s as much as the Cerritos—and the well timed arrival of all the opposite California-Class ships within the fleet, because of a change of coronary heart by Mariner—to cease all of them and save the day, which, in fact, they do. Everyone’s joyful! Boimler asserts his boldness! Rutherford has discovered that means to his historical past! Mariner is again in Starfleet and in her mother’s good books! And… sure, it’s a win, however it additionally means so little that this season finally feels prefer it doesn’t actually matter. We’re largely again to the established order Lower Decks had earlier than the shock of Captain Freeman being arrested in season 2’s closing moments. The truth that everybody on the Cerritos appeared to hate Mariner for betraying them within the final episode, her girlfriend included, can also be brushed apart, so we actually are simply again with Mariner and Carol getting alongside—however given the fast twist on the begin of this season that soured their relationship as Captain and Ensign, what’s to say one thing like that simply couldn’t come out of nowhere once more, and we do that complete arc with them over?

At least some development occurred for the characters past Mariner and her standing as Lower Decks’ defacto protagonist. Tendi’s path to senior officer coaching signifies that we ultimately get to select up on the promise of season 2’s wonderful episode “Wej Duj,” with T’Lyn lastly getting on board the ship as a fresh-faced counterpart to our seasoned Lower Deckers. Now that Rutherford’s backstory has been fleshed out, there’s lots of potential on the stage for Badgey to probably change into a serious villain in season 4. And even when Boimler’s development t o “Bold Boimler” was a bit of slight, it pays off splendidly when he bonds with Shax and will get everybody on the bridge to hearken to the Bajoran’s explosive needs for as soon as.

That’s sufficient that “The Stars at Night” doesn’t really feel like a few of the lows this third season of Lower Decks has endured thus far. There is potential right here, so the up-and-down journey of those ten episodes finally feels price it. For now, it’s a superb factor that Lower Decks appears proper again the place it was coming into season 3… if solely as a result of it makes it a lot simpler to neglect that lots of these lows occurred.

Want extra io9 information? Check out when to anticipate the most recent Marvel and Star Wars releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on movie and TV, and the whole lot you could find out about House of the Dragon and Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power.