Rings of Power’s Quest Stands Upon the Edge of a Knife

Rings of Power has spent its total season reminding us that it, at its core in manners just like Lord of the Rings as an entire, is a story of tolerating hope within the face of seemingly unyielding darkness. This week is way the identical, however it additionally takes a variety of time to permit its heroes to wallow in the truth that seemingly unyielding darkness actually, actually sucks.

“The Eye” is sort of totally in regards to the fallout of final week’s climax within the battle for the Southlands, which noticed the land actually and metaphorically shaken by the cataclysmic creation of Mount Doom. This despair lingers everywhere in the episode, whether or not it’s in its beautiful, haunting opening scene—as a horrified, ash-caked Galadriel wanders via the ruined aftermath of Theo and Bronwyn’s village—and even additional afield, as hunks of molten rock from Doom’s eruption are revealed to have devastated the orchard the Harfoots had been planning emigrate to for the season.

Even in visiting plotlines unaffected by Doom straight, the air of despair weighs heavy—Elrond and Durin, who’ve quietly change into one of many present’s most stunning and enduring relationships, discover themselves torn asunder as their pleas to Durin’s father to mine Mithril to assist the Eldar finish in not simply falling on deaf ears, however mainly destroying Durin’s relationship with the elder Durin totally. And this isn’t only a momentary incident of despair: it simply retains getting worse and worse.

Isildur is “seemingly” misplaced to a crumbling home within the ruins of the village, bringing an unpleasant heartache to his father that laces his relationship with Galadriel with venom. Miriel’s loss is altogether extra bodily, because the crumbling of that aforementioned home leaves her blinded. Even the place there are not any bodily accidents, the psychological scar of traumas are there for all to see throughout the solid: Theo and Galadriel, separated from the remaining survivors as they attempt to make it again to the Númenorean encampment and harassed by now-freely-roaming orcs on this land of limitless ash and evening, bond over their shared despairs that they’re in charge for this calamitous flip of occasions. The Stranger, whose makes an attempt to breath magical life into the ashen timber of the Harfoot’s orchard dwelling nearly result in Nori and her sister being crushed by falling particles, is so horrified at his potential to hurt that he takes his go away of the halflings totally… leaving them susceptible to the mysterious evil-worshippers which have been quietly attempting to find the Stranger to casually and callously flip their encampment to flame.

While “The Eye” does ultimately get to discovering some degree of hope for its heroes, this wallowing within the rise of evil feels not like the present has performed up to now. We don’t want the frankly obtuse last-scene reveal that the Southlands have certainly now change into Mordor, as their map-fonted identify on the display burns out to get replaced with its darkish new title: we’ve got spent your complete episode exploring what it implies that Mordor now exists, that the tide of evil is rising throughout Middle-earth. We see it within the direct despair of the people and Númenoreans, in Galadriel and Theo’s self-doubt, we see it within the choices made in anger and concern by individuals like King Durin and the Stranger. Many instances earlier than has Rings of Power challenged its characters with seemingly overwhelming despair and requested them to beat it, however “The Eye” actually looks like the primary time that they gained’t.

And but, in fact, this can be a story in The Lord of the Rings. Our heroes have to, as a result of Tolkien’s world is one among hope and never cynical despair. And so, little by little, we see sparks, cast in tiny bonds of fellowship. Elrond and Durin’s relationship endures the elder Durin’s makes an attempt to snuff it out, stronger than ever wrought earlier than in touching scenes of teary-eyed intimacy between the 2 males. Theo is reunited with Bronwyn and Arondir on the Númenorean encampment, and his encounter with Galadriel steels him to place apart the doubts that lead him down the trail in direction of Sauron’s cursed blade within the first place. No matter how irrevocably modified Elendil’s relationship with Galadriel is by Isildur’s obvious loss of life—even when we in fact know that’s not the case—her bond with Miriel is cast even tougher, because the latter guarantees to return to Middle-earth with renewed reinforcements and vigor, a treatise not simply with Galadriel however all of Elf-kind. And Nori, Poppy, and Marigold persuade Sadoc that they’ve to assist the Stranger, setting out on roads untravelled by Harfoots in eons to take action.

We know issues need to worsen within the story of the Second Age coming into Rings of Power’s first season finale subsequent week, and in loads of instances to return past it ought to this story proceed. There are hints of it right here and there in “The Eye”—King Durin’s hesitation over Mithril proved proper by the (considerably egregious) tease of the Balrog that lurks the place dwarves will someday delve too deep. It’s maybe there in Halbrand, who does little to assuage all these “is this guy Sauron in disguise” theories by being conveniently discovered on the highway again to the camp by the Númenoreans total high-quality apart from one harm—one not grave sufficient to cease him from driving horseback with Galadriel, and but one grave sufficient that it particularly requires Elvish medication to deal with. But within the right here and now, even in The Rings of Power’s darkest hour, within the delivery of Mordor itself, the present nonetheless shines with a prevailing hope—a hope all of our myriad heroes are going to want quickly sufficient.

Want extra io9 information? Check out when to anticipate the newest Marvel and Star Wars releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on movie and TV, and the whole lot it is advisable learn about House of the Dragon and Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power.