There’s one thing notably apt in regards to the first episode of House of the Dragon, the much-anticipated prequel sequence to Game of Thrones, being in regards to the indecisiveness of King Viserys Targaryen (Paddy Considine) concerning who will succeed him on the Iron Throne. Like its lead character, House of the Dragon is clearly a present attempting to determine what it’s, as a result of it may well’t determine the reply to this query: Exactly how Game of Thrones-y ought to the sequence be?

To be truthful, it’s not precisely a simple query to reply. Millions of individuals watched and cherished Game of Thrones, till they didn’t. House of the Dragon is attempting to remind individuals of what they cherished in regards to the authentic whereas concurrently not reminding them of Thrones’ flaws (lots of which, not coincidentally, began occurring when the present ran out of creator George R.R. Martin’s revealed materials). The result’s that Dragon concurrently tries to be each acquainted and new, and the impact typically finally ends up disconcerting.

Honestly, the start of the premiere is disconcerting sufficient by itself. It begins with a lesson about Targaryen historical past and a flashback scene when the late king’s nephew, a younger Viserys, is chosen to rule the Seven Kingdom as an alternative of the king’s daughter and direct descendent, Rhaenys. Then it cuts to a different little bit of prologue textual content catching as much as the current day, mentioning Viserys’ lengthy, peaceable reign and that the present begins precisely 172 years earlier than Game of Thrones’ Daenerys Targaryen was born. Centering the present in relation to the unique is a sensible choice, however the whole lot else is loads to absorb, particularly when—after an introduction to the current-day Viserys’ daughter Rhaenyra (Milly Alcock) and her buddy Alicent Hightower (Emily Carey)—House of the Dragon instantly heads into a gathering of the King’s Small Council, filled with characters you don’t get sufficient time to determine, not to mention determine their place within the story.

The gist of that story, nevertheless, finally ends up this: King Viserys has no clear successor. There’s his brother Daemon (Matt Smith), the subsequent man in line for the throne, however a merciless, smug man who would clearly be a horrible king. There’s additionally Rhaenyra, who’s younger, form, and sadly additionally a girl in a deeply patriarchal medieval society. Viserys has a possible third possibility that he’s holding out for; his spouse Aemma (Sian Brooke) is nearly to provide start, and a son would settle the query completely. (Yes, sans potential child, that is mainly the identical problem seen within the flashback, which isn’t mandatory to grasp the present story and will have been inserted into the episode way more organically later.)

Viserys is so assured Aemma will give him a boy that he’s introduced a large match (and I do imply large, House of the Dragon clearly has its predecessor’s finances) in celebration, which brings Daemon dwelling to King’s Landing. He’s launched sitting smugly on the Iron Throne, already awaiting his ascension, however then has a young second together with his niece Rhaenyra that reveals he’s not completely terrible… which then will get barely creepy as Smith places out a small vibe that’s disturbingly prurient. Daemon is definitely House of the Dragon’s most fascinating, or a minimum of fascinating, character. In his subsequent scene, he’s main his newly shaped metropolis watch, the Goldcloaks, into the slums of the town to cut off crime-appropriate physique components of thieves, rapists, and murderers, filling two whole wagons with them. When some members of the Small Council complain about it later, others need to level out crime was rampant, and it wanted to be cleaned up earlier than all of the lords and girls arrived for the match. Later, he’s at a brothel, but additionally brazenly exhibits his vulnerability and anguish that he may not sit on the throne he’s needed for therefore lengthy.

But probably the most compelling storyline within the premiere is undoubtedly Aemma’s, which manages to depict the horrors of being a girl in a medieval patriarchy with out being almost as salacious about it as Game of Thrones. The pregnant Aemma tells Viserys that this child have to be her final, and never due to her age however due to her coronary heart. Since Rhaenyra, Aemma’s had one little one who died in infancy, two stillbirths, and two miscarriages, and he or she merely can’t take anymore. And but, early she tells her daughter that giving start is how girls “serve the realms. The childbed is our battlefield.”

This assertion units up probably the most highly effective scene within the premiere. When the match begins, Queen Aemma goes into labor; it’s past tough, and looks like it’s going to find yourself one other stillbirth. Then it will get worse. When the fetus received’t flip correctly, the Maester tells Viserys that he has can enhance the percentages of saving the newborn through a medieval C-section which will certainly kill Aemma, or just threat dropping them each. Viserys, placing the soundness of the realm over his love for his spouse, makes the inconceivable choice and stays by her mattress as she bleeds and screams.

I’ll admit, at first, I assumed this was one other one of many Game of Thrones franchise’s salaciously brutal depictions of violence in direction of girls, particularly because the scene frequently lower backwards and forwards to the match, the place knights had been maiming and killing one another for enjoyable. But because the gore within the match received an increasing number of clearly gratuitous, it dawned on me that this was the purpose: These males had been bleeding and dying for a sport and a few nebulous concept of honor, whereas Aemma was bleeding and dying to stop the Seven Kingdoms from going to conflict. While the knights did it for leisure, Aemma was doing her obligation as deemed by the patriarchy, which included being sacrificed at her husband’s arms. The childbed was a battlefield, upon which Aemma gave her life. The males had been in a goddamned sports activities area.

It’s this scene, this cautious crafting, and this sensibility, the place House of the Dragon outshines Game of Thrones and showcases its potential to do higher. As is the scene the place Aemma is on her funeral pyre, wrapped in bandages… and the digicam slowly pans right down to reveal a a lot smaller physique in bandages mendacity subsequent to the queen, then shortly cuts away. Yes, the kid—a boy—has died as effectively, a devastating realization for the characters and viewers alike, however Dragon doesn’t linger on or wallow within the horror. The impact is highly effective with out feeling just like the “misery porn” that Thrones was typically accused of being.

And but, in some methods, House of the Dragon clearly feels the have to be a GoT cowl band. Is there a gratuitous intercourse scene? Yes. Is there a gratuitous orgy scene? Of course. Does a seemingly good man and Hand of the King, Otto Hightower (Rhys Ifans), ship his younger daughter Alicent to “comfort” the king in his grief? Unfortunately, sure. Does a rapist have his balls lower off and are these severed testicles thrown onto one thing after which graphically proven as a pile of bloody goo? That’s a really bizarre query, however sure.

But in that intercourse scene, the one nudity is Matt Smith and his consort’s butts. Even the extra graphic nudity of the orgy felt toned down in comparison with Thrones. Despite Otto’s clear try to make his king fall for his daughter, the scene quantities to nothing as a result of Viserys remains to be grieving and under no circumstances licentious. And for the balls… look, it’s undoubtedly gross and a bizarre choice for the present to make, however a minimum of it occurs to a anonymous rapist who’s by no means seen once more and isn’t one of many important characters.

That orgy scene, by the best way, is the place Daemon messes up. Surrounded by partying, sycophantic Goldcloaks, he dubs the toddler “Heir for a Day,” which Otto, a famous Daemon-hater, reviews to Viserys with impressively hid satisfaction. Furious at and disgusted with the brother he’s defended for therefore lengthy, Viserys banishes Daemon from King’s Landing and formally names Rhaenyra as his successor to all of the attendant lords. It’s extraordinarily clear not all of these lords swearing fealty to a girl are glad about it. Oh, and keep in mind Rhaenys (Eve Best)? She has to observe her niece obtain the prize she misplaced regardless of them being in primarily the identical place, and her expression is inscrutable.

All in all, House of the Dragon has an amazing premise for a medieval fantasy political thriller. The oking is depressing and has a mysterious however clearly contaminated wound that would finish his reign a lot sooner than anticipated. The inheritor obvious is his daughter—who’s young, inexperienced, and fairly actually threatening social and political norms. And the king’s brother, who brazenly desires the throne, has his personal supporters, together with a small however extremely loyal military contained in the capital. And then there are all the opposite lords and girls, some merely pawns, however many who see a chance to rise in energy… and possibly even rule.

Time will inform if House of the Dragon will emerge absolutely from Game of Thrones’ shadow, retreat completely into it, or frequently straddle the road. But there’s one nice benefit that House of the Dragon has that Game of Thrones didn’t—George R.R. Martin has already completed this story.

Assorted Musings:

• That story, by the best way, is informed in Fire & Blood, which is mainly Martin’s historical past textbook of Targaryen rule in Westeros, together with occasions earlier than and after these being informed in House of the Dragon. If you need to learn it, simply understand it’s additionally written like a historical past textbook and never a correct novel, which implies it may well sometimes be dry or throw so many individuals’s names at you with out context your head will explode.
• I apologize for not checking out all these aforementioned different characters and their locations within the story, however they play very minor roles within the premiere and this recap went longer than lengthy anyway. Their time will come each within the present and the recaps, presumably.
• I don’t fairly get the match guidelines on this premiere, which looks like the knightly model of “no holds barred.” I’m used to knights jousting with agency guidelines about the place lances can strike, and when one is unseated and desires to combat, his opponent additionally will get off his horse. But Daemon straight-up murders a dude’s horse, somebody will get suplexed off his horse by one other man, and hitting individuals once they’re down and unconscious is outwardly effective, even should you’re caving their face in.
• I like that Viserys is making a large mannequin of King’s Landing as a pastime. It’s mainly these large practice units some individuals make, besides earlier than trains.
• Viserys is unable to sit down upon the Iron Throne with out reducing himself, which is an apparent metaphor for his weak spot as a king. However, the dude managed to sit down on that throne for many years whereas sustaining peace. That ought to earn him some respect.
• Okay, I’ve to speak in regards to the different a part of the episode’s ending, however I don’t need to as a result of it’s dumb. Viserys tells Rhaenyra the key of the Targaryens, particularly that Aegon, the primary king of Westeros, didn’t cross the ocean simply to beat it. Instead, he had a dream of White Walkers invading the world of males, and that each one the individuals of Westeros would have to be united towards them with a Targaryen in cost. It needlessly connects House of the Dragon to the occasions of Game of Thrones, and it’s simply actually silly and likewise only some of the Houses of Westeros banded collectively to cease the Walkers and Daenerys wasn’t even sitting on the Iron Throne at that time anyway so the dream is dumb and unsuitable and if by some means this nonsense turns into an essential a part of the sequence I will likely be extraordinarily disenchanted.

Want extra io9 information? Check out when to count on the most recent Marvel and Star Wars releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on movie and TV, and the whole lot you might want to learn about House of the Dragon and Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power.