Doctor Who Ends Jodie Whittaker’s Era With an Infuriating Mess

The period of the thirteenth Doctor is over, and it went out how finally a lot of Chris Chibnall’s time as Doctor Who’s showrunner went over the final 4 years: with moments of brilliance outshined by a plodding, unwieldy mess of narratives that threatened to pull its wonderful star down with it. In that means, it’s maybe a becoming finale, if an unjust one.

“The Power of the Doctor,” the ultimate outing of Jodie Whittaker’s thirteenth Doctor and Chris Chibnall’s run as Doctor Who’s showrunner, is, like plenty of the duo’s current escapades in time and house, a troublesome piece of tv to put in writing about. Endings are arduous, particularly Doctor Who ones, the place the magical strategy of Time Lord regeneration all however ensures that irrespective of how sturdy the journey earlier than it, an finish will all the time be outshadowed by the brand new starting that comes instantly after it. They’re even more durable in Doctor Who’s revived period, the place the exit of 1 Doctor and the arrival of one other has, each as soon as in a whereas, additionally coincided with the departure of the present’s flagship inventive steward, turning the story into not simply the tip of a Doctor’s incarnation, however a treatise on a whole interval of Doctor Who’s historical past.

All this and extra hangs closely on the shoulders of “The Power of the Doctor,” an endcap on a tumultuous interval of Doctor Who already closely shadowed by the bananas potential of the returning faces which have lengthy been heralding its future earlier than we reached this finish. There are few finales that would navigate the advanced, nuanced weirdness of the present state of Doctor Who and are available out largely immaculate. But the deadly drawback with “The Power of the Doctor” is that for the overwhelming majority of its burdensome 90-minute runtime it doesn’t even attempt, flinging cameos, story threads, and scenes at a wall and desperately praying that they are going to stick—and for probably the most half, they don’t.

To try to elucidate what occurs in “The Power of the Doctor” narratively is an train in futility. Which is presumably why on the apex of its mess—a second the place the Master (a returned Sacha Dhawan, now having given up any try and be menacing in favor of, like all good Masters earlier than him, consuming each piece of surroundings possible by a BBC price range) units the stage for a zany try and pressure the Doctor to regenerate into himself and breaking out into an prolonged dance sequence set to Boney M’s disco classic “Rasputin”—is heralded by the Master making an attempt to clarify why the previous 45 minutes of the episode had occurred to the Doctor and the viewers.

A prepare flying by house invaded by Cybermen, barely arrived companion Dan quickly exiting the sequence with little in the way in which of emotional payoff, renegade Daleks invading earth, a planet in orbit made out of Cybermen Stuff, UNIT and never one however two returned companions (Janet Fielding and Sophie Aldred as Fifth Doctor companion Tegan Jovanka and Seventh Doctor companion Ace, respectively), lacking work and seismologists, and the Master pretending to be Grigori Rasputin in early twentieth century Siberia… all of this stuff unfold in as incoherent a fashion as attainable. Chibnall’s fondness for title playing cards with areas and years on them in an try and manufacture scale with out truly exhibiting scale is simply matched for his fondness for plot threads that may barely circulate with one another, because the Doctor and Yaz race throughout house and time to attempt to determine what’s going, dragging the viewers alongside the way in which. Scenes barely cohere from one second to the following, and characters determine issues out not by truly working them out from clues, however by simply merely loudly stating what’s meant to occur or is within the strategy of taking place, and none of those seven totally different plot threads get any time to develop as a result of we’re flipping between them at at such a speedy, muddled tempo.

Nothing lands emotionally, regardless of the very fact we’re always shouted at that this stuff are all dire and that the Doctor is going through her hardest battle but. Whittaker barely will get to play to her strengths as she is shuffled between being flummoxed by every newly launched plot thread. No time is spent growing these kernels of concepts—which, standalone or in a a lot smaller dose, is likely to be attention-grabbing episodes in and of themselves, however not right here—so nothing ever feels thrilling or satisfying. And then all of them collapse within the aforementioned scene, the place the Master merely explains, earlier than his dance sequence, that every thing was his thought. Why? Because he stated so. And once more, there’s no satisfaction for the viewers right here, as if this was a grand puzzle you might conceivably put collectively earlier than the Master reveals his, properly, Master plan—as a result of nothing is given the time to make sense. Why does any of this matter? The Master did it. So what?

This would possibly all sound like I’m about to explain this reveal, and the upcoming pressured Master-ification of the Doctor, as a turning level the place “The Power of the Doctor” would possibly get good, however alas. It simply retains including extra plot threads. The Master’s aim? Become the Doctor and seemingly kill their regenerative line within the course of, so he can proceed to slander the Doctor’s identify throughout house and time. The UNIT stuff with Ace and Tegan? Now that’s a Cyberman invasion of Just One Building on Earth, lead by “Last Cyberman” Ashad from a number of seasons in the past (he bought higher, cloned by the Master, don’t fear about it, as a result of “The Power of the Doctor” actually doesn’t after stating this). Remember Vinder from final 12 months’s horrible season, Flux? He’s additionally right here on the Cyber Planet, as a result of it seems that the kid the Cybermen kidnapped on that prepare 45 minutes in the past is definitely sentient vitality powering it. Meanwhile the thirteenth Doctor is shunted to the “Edge of Eternity,” the limbo all Time Lords apparently stroll by in the course of the strategy of regeneration to have a chat with a phasing facsimile of their First, Five, Sixth, Seventh, and Eighth incarnations—the primary of loads wild, random cameos from Doctor Who’s previous. She’s additionally exhibiting up as a sentient AI on the TARDIS to assist the deserted Yaz, and as implanted holograms for Tegan and Ace as they’re shunted into separate plotlines to cease the separate Dalek and Cyberman threats.

Once once more, individually, all these threads would possibly make for compelling Doctor Who episodes. And there are concepts right here that, for a quick second within the muddling malaise, shine with a superb potential that simply makes their bigger messiness much more irritating. The thought of a limbo for Doctors the place their previous selves, so horrified by the Master’s vandalizing of regeneration, come collectively to drag the thirteenth Doctor again from the brink is an excellent bridge throughout so many eras of the present. Giving Janet Fielding and Sophie Aldred, two actors whose companions unjustly exited their instances on the present, the possibility for another scene reverse their respective Doctors and provides Tegan and Ace an opportunity to heal their frayed relationship with the Doctor, delivers two extremely poignant moments in an episode of determined want of them. Even the Master’s supposed grand plan—changing into the Doctor simply to defame them throughout the cosmos—is a daring and splendidly Master-esque scheme. But these are simply particular person moments, flickering out and in of brilliance earlier than the incoherence that drives “The Power of the Doctor” sweeps them away too.

The ultimate insult maybe comes with the truth that for on a regular basis “The Power of the Doctor” spends haphazardly chasing between all of those plots, it brings all of them collectively and offers with all of them within the house of 5 to 10 minutes, after Yaz and Vinder handle to revert the Doctor again to herself with a handwave, letting her gleefully hop round within the TARDIS and decide up the myriad companions strewn throughout these far-flung plotlines. Nothing feels satisfying, as a result of it simply seems like a guidelines, and nobody feels something about their decision within the story as a result of they’re there to be scooped up and plopped into the following handwave. And in any case that? It’s solely then that one thing truly occurs to the Doctor to trigger her long-fated regeneration—nearly as an apart greater than the rest. As the Doctor checks off “stop that Cyber planet from existing” from her listing of issues to do, a stray laser beam from the sentient vitality creature from the beginning of the episode catches each the Doctor and the Master (did I point out the Master was nonetheless alive after the entire regenerative physique switcheroo? Anyway, yeah), seemingly mortally wounding them each.

It’s solely right here that “The Power of the Doctor” deigns to recollect it’s a farewell to the most recent model of its titular hero, and the good frustrations of the previous 70 minutes give approach to an finish that, on the entire, feels rather more earned than something that got here earlier than it. Accepting her finish, the Doctor and Yaz share one final second collectively, brushing on the romantic emotions they have for one another however sadly altogether too cowardly to really do greater than brush up on them. Parting methods one final time, it’s revealed to Yaz (due to a passing by Graham and Dan) that they and different previous companions of the Doctor—Ian Chesterton, Mel Bush, Jo Grant, Tegan, and Ace amongst them—have arrange a help group for previous buddies of the Doctor to share their tales, love, and grief with one another, the ability of the Doctor themselves eventually changing into obvious. Whittaker’s ultimate moments in her regeneration are likewise touching, because the Doctor’s ultimate responsibility is a becoming goodbye to her TARDIS—an exquisite mirror to an period that began along with her flung from it—as she takes it to see one final dawn earlier than she herself burns with the regenerative fireplace of a star.

It’s nearly sufficient to make the remainder of “The Power of the Doctor” value it, these previous few moments, however maybe in probably the most becoming transfer of all for an period outlined by Whittaker’s brilliance usually being undercut by the moray of messing storytelling thrust upon her, even her ultimate moments rob her of the true highlight—as she burns away to not reveal Ncuti Gatwa as her successor, however the returned David Tennant. And “burn away” seems like an apt descriptor right here, not only for the regeneration vitality cascading by the Time Lord, however the truth that even the Doctor’s very garments burn away, changing them with an outfit evocative of the Tenth Doctor’s prior chosen look. It’s as if even the custom of the previous Doctor’s garments lasting at the very least a part of an journey past them was an excessive amount of credit score to present, as we rush alongside into the nostalgic return of certainly one of Doctor Who’s most beloved stars, all “what what what”-ing and recognising their very own familiarity.

And so, the thirteenth Doctor’s period ends, concluding in a fashion just like a lot of her time within the TARDIS: with a narrative struggled to understand what made her such a compelling incarnation within the first place, burdened with complicated spectacle over an precise coronary heart. As our eyes now look to the way forward for Doctor Who—full of nostalgia and refreshment alike—it’s maybe for one of the best that we do as we’re inspired, and never dwell upon the errors of the previous. Maybe the true energy of the Doctor is to easily settle for the change given to us, and transfer on as shortly as Doctor Who itself has into a brand new journey.

Want extra io9 information? Check out when to count on the most recent Marvel and Star Wars releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on movie and TV, and every thing it’s essential to learn about House of the Dragon and Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power.