“Remember this: Try,” evokes the voice of Karis Nemik in Andor’s unbelievable finale, the spirited conclusion to the manifesto he’ll by no means get to see the tip results of—a line that, within the second, appears like a pointed rejoinder to the philosophy of the Jedi which can be solely absent from the present. But for all their literal opposites, possibly there’s extra in widespread between Yoda and Nemik’s beliefs.

On the floor, and with some added background—specifically, the Clone Wars and the Prequel Trilogy giving us not-entirely-glowing perception into what Yoda was like earlier than he was a hermit mystic, peacing out of the Empire’s dominance of the galaxy in Empire Strikes Back—putting Nemik’s passionate name for resistance subsequent to the venerable Jedi Master appears like a potent strike in Star Wars’ rising recontextualization of the low the Jedi Order was at after we encounter it within the films. It’s the thought that everybody taking any act of revolt is of profit to a collective rebel of the entire, even when they don’t know that there are others on the market preventing the identical struggle they’re.

Before its destruction by the hands of Palpatine’s subterfuge as a Sith, we’re reminded time and time once more of the Jedi’s recalcitrance as arbiters of justice and defenders of the widespread individuals, of how non secular leaders like Yoda and the remainder of the Jedi council are clouded by clinging to a hypocritical sense of orthodoxy even because it units the stage for their inevitable damage. Even with out the affect of their notorious foes—a menace ignored till it was too late—the Jedi Order was in a spiral of decline, as a moralistic entity and as an institutional arm of the Republic, laying the trail of their undoing and the rise of Imperial authoritarianism on a street of their very own inaction. In this learn of the Jedi, the one we’re given within the prequels and in materials like Clone Wars, Yoda’s phrases uttered to Luke in Empire Strikes Back really feel nearly merciless of their hypocrisy—how dare Yoda lecture somebody on making an attempt to do one thing, when he idly stood by as Anakin was pushed additional down a darkish path, when within the wake of the Empire’s rise, Yoda determined to run away till a baby he may wield as a device towards the Emperor had come of age?

It is towards this essential interpretation of Yoda’s platitudes that Nemik’s manifesto in Andor stands most starkly in distinction. Andor is a collection that is freed from lots of the legendary and non secular trappings of different Star Wars materials: the Force isn’t talked about and neither are the Jedi, there aren’t any magic powers and laser swords, there are simply bizarre beings navigating a galaxy within the grip of overwhelming fascism. Nemik’s phrases don’t implore individuals to leverage a godlike energy they will faucet into with sufficient effort (and, with the context of the prequels, successful a genetic lottery) or do nothing in any respect, however merely to maintain attempting, that perseverance within the face of darkness will convey life. Random acts of revolt are all over the place, he says to us and Cassian alike; everybody concerned in them helps one another even when they don’t comprehend it, and the bigger trigger is superior in methods huge and small with each act taken towards the Empire. It’s lovely, in comparison with the unfeeling backhanded recommendation of Yoda—so long as you attempt, so long as you might be courageous sufficient to take any act of resistance, you might be a part of one thing greater, one thing spreading throughout all the galaxy.

But it’s doable to additionally think about Nemik and Yoda’s phrases in lockstep with one another, in a method, speaking about related objectives however with totally different languages. When Yoda tells Luke—who says in despair that he’ll by no means have the ability to use the Force to elevate an X-Wing out of Dagobah’s swamp, however at the least he’ll attempt—“Do or do not, there is no ‘try’,” Star Wars’ understanding of the Force was very totally different to the context wherein we perceive it in the present day, the methods we now have seen it defined and deployed past the obscure, mystical scope of the unique trilogy. What Yoda is saying to him isn’t that there’s no level in attempting in any respect, however that Luke has to beat his doubt to totally wield the Force as a Jedi ought to—that there isn’t a distinction when it comes to impossibility between lifting a rock together with your thoughts to lifting a starfighter. If you are able to do one, you are able to do the opposite, since you are putting your belief on this increased connective energy that binds all the universe collectively. If you consider within the Force, that each dwelling factor within the pure world is related by it, that there’s a higher magical complete that you simply too are a part of and have discovered to just accept and name upon, you possibly can obtain the inconceivable.

Nemik is speaking about a lot the identical factor, he’s simply speaking about it in a fabric method, with out the non secular language of the Force or the Jedi that Yoda and Luke have. Fundamentally, he too is imploring individuals to beat doubt; whereas the ability of the Empire’s authority appears all-encompassing and steadfast, so long as individuals have the religion to try to push again towards it, they may help the bigger rebel’s effort, and that in the end they are going to be related to a trigger past the private scope of their very own revolt. Andor, for all of the literal absence of Star Wars’ ordinary mysticism, continues to be a deeply non secular present. It simply occurs to put these concepts in context of human emotion and connection as an alternative of in an exterior vitality just like the Force.

We could chortle and joke at The Rise of Skywalker’s opening line (“The Dead Speak!”), however in Andor they actually do, one thing extra literal than a Force ghost in recorded messages like Nemik’s manifesto or Maarva’s hologram at her personal funeral, and one thing equally ephemeral within the ways in which Cassian recollects the recommendation of his adoptive father Clem when he brushes his father’s funerary stone upon returning to Ferrix. If the true increased energy of the Force is in a shared connection throughout not simply dwelling issues however throughout generations of individuals who believed in it, passing on to turn into a part of this bigger calling however nonetheless capable of information these left behind, Andor believes in an analogous factor as effectively, in issues just like the traditions of Ferrix’s funeral rites, in Nemik’s dying want to be for Cassian to obtain his manifesto manuscript, and even within the thought of Luthen sacrificing his personal existence for, as he says nearly bitterly, a dawn he is aware of he’ll by no means see.

When it involves doing or not doing, or remembering to attempt, in the long run Nemik and Yoda need the identical factor: for individuals to comprehend that they aren’t alone, and that so long as they consider they will forge a bond with a complete galaxy of existence and face the inconceivable. And that in the event that they achieve this, they could simply even have the religion to beat it.

Want extra io9 information? Check out when to anticipate the most recent Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on movie and TV, and all the pieces you could find out about James Cameron’s Avatar: The Way of Water.