Disenchanted, the direct-to-Disney+ sequel for the very best Disney live-action fairy story movie, is held collectively by the magic that’s Amy Adams. The story, sadly, lacks sufficient of its personal magic to really feel utterly satisfying.

In the earlier movie, Enchanted, her Giselle was a pleasant princess-to-be trope that got here to life and located herself in modern-day New York City. She found there’s extra to life than “true love’s kiss” and ended up with Robert (Patrick Dempsey), a hotshot lawyer, fairly than excellent himbo prince Edward (James Marsden). The first movie captured the sincerity of striving to maintain the very best of fairytale beliefs in a world that might use a little bit magic—whereas breaking the tropes that wanted to be damaged in actual life by way of music and climactic motion (shout out to Susan Sarandon for being a scrumptious dragon villain).

In Disenchanted, we discover Giselle looking for methods to recapture magic in her life. Her household has outgrown their NYC condo, her stepdaughter Morgan (now performed by Gabriella Baldacchino) is a teen, and their household has welcomed a brand new child, Sofia. So they determine to uproot to suburbia, Monroeville—a not-so-idyllic place, regardless of outward appearances, the place mean-girl mother Malvina Monroe (Maya Rudolph) and her two minions (Jayme Mays and Yvette Nicole Brown) run the present.

Seeing that suburbia just isn’t all that it’s cracked as much as be and with a teen who misses her previous life within the metropolis, Giselle takes issues in her personal palms when the chance presents itself. It does so within the type of Edward and Nancy (Idina Menzel), who as Sofia’s magical godparents reward the kid a wishing wand, since she’s a daughter of Andalasia. The set-up is intelligent; after a battle with Morgan, who calls her “step-mother” out of anger regardless of the shut relationship that they had within the first movie, Giselle makes use of the wand to summon the type of fairytale life that drew Morgan to her once they first met.

When Giselle wakes up, Monroeville is a kingdom, not not like those we’ve seen in collection like Galavant and Once Upon a Time. And that’s the place the film type of misplaced me. It shortly falls into a really related world we’ve seen executed greater than as soon as by Disney, however with the Fairytale Core filter turned up and populated by a lot better actors (Disenchanted does them a disservice, actually). That mentioned, the costumes on “good” Giselle and Morgan are immaculate and really feel like fashionable fantasy style home Selkie meets Disney.

G/O Media could get a fee

An ultra-smart air monitor
or Black Friday, uHoo is $140 off its unique value, plus you’ll get one 12 months of uHoo’s Premium plan, with personalized alerts about air high quality.

Speaking of “good” Giselle, Adams doesn’t miss a step in recreating the optimistic, wide-eyed spirit from the primary movie. When the crux of the plot is launched—her want makes her a depraved step-mother by the hour—it’s offered as a improbable twist, however the thought turns into disjointed because the movie goes on. There are too many plot threads, between Giselle’s relationship with Morgan that tries to be the principle focus, however then there’s additionally Giselle versus Malvina for the crown. Nevertheless, Adams relishes in being “bad” Giselle in an astounding approach and completely nails having two completely different and excellent contrasting energies.

The B-plots additionally get messy with a lot of characters you usually would have needed extra of. Dempsey is given two-dimensional arc as Robert looking for a objective in a fairytale world as a hapless hero, which is senseless to who he was earlier than. Morgan additionally has a love story that might have been extra outstanding to promote us on it. And then there’s Nancy and Edward who simply come to save lots of the day, be saved, and save the day once more; Nancy will get the total Fairy Godmother therapy with the movie’s principal musical numbers. At least Menzel lastly will get to sing! Rudolph additionally elevates each scene and musical quantity she’s in as the proper foil to “bad” Giselle.

Overall, it’s nice to see all these characters again and riffing on numerous fairytale tropes surrounding queens and daughters; it largely works, largely due to the solid’s dedication to their roles. It’s a disgrace the story doesn’t dwell as much as the primary movie—perhaps it ought to have been a mini-series as an alternative, to raised serve the varied threads and relationships that author Brigitte Hales and director Adam Shankman clearly needed to discover. I do hope it’s not the final we see of the characters and there’s extra chapters on the planet of Enchanted to see.

Disenchanted is now streaming on Disney+.

Want extra io9 information? Check out when to count on the newest Marvel and Star Wars releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on movie and TV, and every little thing it’s essential to find out about House of the Dragon and Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power.