Biden Admin Says IPCC ‘Does Not Present Sufficient Cause’ to End Offshore Drilling

This piece was originally published in the Daily Poster, a grassroots-funded investigative information outlet. Click here to become a subscriber.

President Joe Biden has been touring climate-ravaged areas of America, warning that local weather change is a “code red” emergency for the planet. And but, his administration has continued to spice up fossil gas initiatives and is now getting ready to vastly increase offshore drilling.

The White House argues {that a} court docket order it opposes and is interesting requires federal officers to lease greater than 78 million acres of the Gulf of Mexico for fossil gas exploration. Environmental teams, nevertheless, assert that federal regulation provides the administration broad discretion over whether or not or to not maintain such gross sales.

In truth, Biden’s officers have as an alternative used that energy to formally declare that the warnings within the current Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) report “does not present sufficient cause” to reevaluate the drilling plan.

With the assistance of the nonprofit public curiosity group Earthjustice, several environmental and Gulf groups have now launched a lawsuit in opposition to the administration to cease the Gulf lease sale. The criticism argues that the environmental evaluation behind the lease sale is predicated on outdated and arbitrary science, in violation of federal regulation.

“We’ve been very patient with his administration,” says Hallie Templeton, deputy authorized director for Friends of the Earth, one of many environmental teams concerned within the litigation. “The honeymoon’s over. It’s now September, they’ve been in office for eight months. It’s time for them to show that they have priorities and are meaningfully going to move in the right direction.”

Undercutting The Message

As Biden final week sounded the local weather alarm throughout a tour of East Coast locales slammed by Hurricane Ida, his personal administration was undercutting the message, shifting ahead with a fossil gas lease sale within the Gulf of Mexico that started beneath Donald Trump’s presidency.

Announcement of the lease sale for extra drilling arrived on the heels of a sobering new report from the IPCC, which warned of catastrophic weather-related penalties ought to the world’s powers not radically decarbonize. The report pinned the blame for the disaster squarely on human exercise, equivalent to fossil gas extraction. The UN’s World Meteorological Organization additionally lately launched a examine indicating that weather-related pure disasters have increased fivefold during the last 4 a long time.

At a press convention this week, Biden as soon as once more acknowledged the prices of local weather change, calling for America to “get real” about the issue.

“Extreme weather cost America last year $99 billion,” he stated. “And it’s gonna break the record this year; it’s gonna be well over $100 billion.”

‘Billions Of Dollars At Stake’

Back in January, every week after taking workplace, Biden issued an govt order pausing “new oil and natural gas leases on public lands or in offshore waters, pending completion of a comprehensive review and reconsideration of Federal oil and gas permitting and leasing practices.” As a part of his order, the Secretary of the Interior Department was directed to evaluate current permits for fossil gas extraction.

Not lengthy after the order, the administration introduced it was canceling the planned lease sales of 78.2 million acres within the Gulf of Mexico, earlier than the bidding course of was set to start in March. The administration additionally canceled the public comment period that was set to steer as much as the lease gross sales of 1 million acres in Alaska’s Cook Inlet. Later, the Interior Department additionally canceled lease sales on public lands in Colorado, Montana, Nevada, New Mexico, Utah, and Wyoming.

The order was an effort to make good on a forceful campaign promise Biden had made to finish drilling on federal land, which is chargeable for about a quarter of U.S. carbon emissions.

In response to Biden’s order, 13 Republican states — Alabama, Alaska, Arkansas, Louisiana, Georgia, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Oklahoma, Texas, Utah, and West Virginia — sued the administration to restart the leasing program within the Gulf of Mexico, Alaska, and Western States. Wyoming additionally sued in a separate swimsuit.

The state attorneys normal concerned within the swimsuit had been all members of the fossil fuel-funded Republican Attorneys General Association. Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall is the affiliation’s coverage chairman.

In June, a Trump-appointed federal decide in Louisiana, Terry Doughty, granted the 13 states a nationwide preliminary injunction in opposition to Biden’s moratorium, directing the leasing program be resumed. Doughty ordered that the administration was particularly barred from implementing the pause with reference to the lease gross sales within the Gulf and Alaska.

“Millions and possibly billions of dollars are at stake,” Doughty wrote.

Following the ruling, the Republican states concerned within the lawsuit filed a movement to carry the Interior Department in contempt for refusing to comply with the order. The movement sought to compel the division to carry the Gulf of Mexico lease sale.

In response, the administration filed notice that it was appealing the decide’s order, in addition to a defiant brief difficult the Republican states’ movement on the grounds that the court docket order did “not compel Interior to take the actions specified by plaintiffs, let alone on the urgent timeline specified in plaintiffs’ contempt motion.”

Nevertheless, on September 1, days after submitting the temporary, the White House posted a brand new Record of Decision on-line stating it will be shifting ahead with the Gulf of Mexico lease sale, and saying that the IPCC report wouldn’t change its environmental views on the plan.

“The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change released a new report detailing observations of a rapidly changing climate in every region globally, the decision said. “This report does not present sufficient cause to supplement the (environmental impact statement) at this time.”

‘Pandering To Both Sides’

Environmental activists say the administration may very well be taking a harder stand on drilling on public lands and offshore.

“If the administration’s going to appeal that [order], why not seek a stay to allow them to continue the pause while the appeal is going forward?” Templeton says. “It’s really confusing what’s going on here, it’s like they’re pandering to both sides in a way.”

Even with out such a keep, Brettny Hardy, a senior legal professional at Earthjustice, says federal regulation grants the federal government discretion over whether or not or to not maintain lease gross sales.

“Initially, the reason that they gave when they canceled the lease sale is that there was a pause from the executive order,” she says. “So they can’t decide to cancel the lease sale because of the pause, because the pause is no longer enforced right now. But they could cancel the lease sale for any number of other reasons, including the fact that they don’t have adequate environmental analysis.”

According to Hardy, the environmental impression assertion required for the Gulf lease sale is now old-fashioned as a result of it was accomplished years in the past, earlier than recent advances in attribution science that extra intently linked human exercise and excessive results of local weather change.

Templeton says the administration’s choice that the dire new IPCC report “does not present sufficient cause” to conduct a brand new environmental evaluation doesn’t make sense.

“Why rely on five-year-old environmental analyses to continue this permitting when the law is clear [that] you’ve got to have updated analysis and rely on the best available science?” she says. “We have science since 2016 showing that climate change is worse than ever and our timeline is not a long one to reverse course.”